Wednesday, September 9, 2009

The evil profit motive

I don't want to spend a bunch of time defending myself. I'd rather spend it on the ideas. I'll just say there is a difference between confidence in one's convictions and the blind faith of ideology and let the reader decide which I display.

You can hate the profit motive and proclaim that it shouldn't exist, but that's going to get you as far as demonizing your car for demanding fuel.

It's telling that Matt suggests he doesn't care if the system collapses. It will serve the greedy insurance companies right. Is that the real issue? We're going to punish the rich by destroying the economy? Okay. Poverty doesn't scare me. I've been there. It sucks, but I can deal with it. Just keep in mind that there will be nobody to soak when we're done.

I know the plan says you can keep the exact same policy you have now if you want. Everyone will be covered. No limits, no denials and it will all cost less. Keep saying it over and over and maybe it will come true.

Those evil insurance companies are comprised of actual human beings. Those human beings are going to walk away and do something else when it no longer makes sense to work in the insurance biz. Then health care will be administered by politicians, and what a wonderful world it will be.

None for me thanks.

Health Care for All Americans

A battle of ideas can get boring quick, so let's start with a joke: What do you call a 22-year-old cancer patient with health insurance? A Canadian.
My ol' schoolchum Ed has many fine qualities, but he is an ideologue. This is to say that he will argue passionately and often against his own interests. I'm reminded of the great headline from The Onion: "ACLU Defends Nazis' Right to Burn Down ACLU Headquarters."
Ed's a hardworking, self-employed guy for whom a serious ailment or injury would likely mean bankruptcy. Yet his utter distrust of our democratically elected, representational government leads him to fear and oppose the easy solution to the health care crisis in America. Namely, a single payer system. It's simple, and works like this: If you've got health insurance you like, keep it. If you can't afford it or were otherwise rejected by cherry-picking insurance firms, you're covered. The government has your back. You deserve it. Why? You're an American.
Yet somehow this prospect fills Ed with dread for his children's future. He pitys the poor insurer, struggling to meet the mandates of an authoritarian state. The fact is, the insurer is the problem in the equation, and this is where Ed and I really differ.
We are agreed that to provide health care, we need doctors, nurses, hospitals and janitors. And we need someone to pay them. Fine. But why do we need health insurance companies and their profit motive? We don't.
Consider this: Over half of all Americans are in some way covered under federal programs (Medicare, Medicaid, the VA). The administrative costs under these federal programs are about 4 percent of the total spent. The same cost for a private insurance company? About 20 percent. Why is it higher? Well, the profit motive of course. They have to pay their CEOs and top executives those multimillion dollar salaries, and then there are the advertising expenses. Don't forget the investor class, they get their share too.
Ed is afraid this lovely system will collapse if there is a public option. It might, and I don't care.
I am tired of seeing the outrageous, double-digit increases in health insurance premiums that we paid year after year after year. I am tired of seeing my friends limp around in pain or go without medication for lack of money to go to the doctor. A couple years ago I attended the funeral of a woman my age who died because she had no health insurance, didn't get care and died, alone in her room.
Let's just say that woman needed $6,000 worth of care a month, Ed. Let's say she got it, and was alive to make more money, pay taxes and premiums, to bear and raise children, for many years to come. Would her contribution in life make up for the financial loss to her insurer? Obviously the health care companies -- being privately held, for profit corporations -- had no vested interest in keeping her alive. But America did. America could have benefitted from her preservation. America lost.
It is sad and ironic to me that health insurance for all is where my conservative friends have drawn the line in the sand. They trust the government to run our beloved Army, Air Force, Navy and Marines, at a cost of dizzying billions annually. They trust the government to insure their bank deposits. They trust in the roads and bridges and waterways we all pay to build and maintain. Yet they cannot fathom that it is a democratically elected government's right or responsibility to step in and offer a solution -- to just pay the damn bill -- when the free market refuses or declines to provide care to their fellow Americans.
Ed seems to worry that the elimination of the profit motive from the health care industry will lead to the ruin of America. I say the profit motive has ruined health care, and is killing America as we speak. I say, let private insurance companies perish. That's what they've been saying to millions of Americans, like my late friend, for years.

Tuesday, September 8, 2009

Health Care - Again

By Ed

Alright, let's get to the heart of the issue here. Instead of each of us beating each other over the head about how wrong the other is, let's try focusing on the common ground.

The goal is to try to enable affordable access to health care for everyone. The challenge is that health care doesn't just fall from the sky or grow wild in the back yard. It's a service that requires labor, resources and time. It requires someone to work. I'm going to assume we're both opposed to slavery, so that's out. Forcing someone to work for less than they believe it's worth is also out. (That's just modified slavery). So, if it's going to be done, there must be another way to go.

The government has proven time and time again that putting them in charge of huge piles of money is a horrible, horrible idea. Let's think of something else. All of the proposals on the table at the moment are just round about ways of forcibly taking money from one group and giving it to another.

I'm not opposed to healthy, happy people. I've nothing against the working poor. I am the working poor. Contrary to reports, I don't feel like my ranks are swelling (I actually lost a few pounds this year.) What I'm opposed to is watching the nation commit economic suicide.

Most of the issues aren't that hard to deal with. They can be addressed by opening up the markets for health care insurance and health care itself. There are currently so many restrictions in the name of consumer protection that choices are very limited and expensive. For example, I can't just buy a $50/month policy that only covers broken bones. States have mandated coverages that must include everything from a broken pinky to a sex change operation. A clinic that wanted to provide only first aid would be faced with so much exposure to liability, they wouldn't be able to afford band aids. Like I said, these types of issues are easy. A little common sense could fix most of them.

The real tough one is pre-existing conditions. The President has stated that any health care reform package must include the requirement that insurance companies cover everyone, regardless of pre-existing conditions. This is one point that his opponents have even agreed to. In fact, the vast majority of the public is on board with this one. Here's the problem. I walk into an insurance company with an ailment that requires $6,000 worth of medical treatment every month for the rest of my life. The company is required by law to sell me a policy for $500/month. How do you make the math work on that one? You don't. Private health insurance becomes a thing of the past. We will have government run health insurance, and the math wont work any better for the government than it did in the private sector.

The good news for pubic health insurance proponents is that it's probably inevitable. I believe my children's children will be sitting around the housing project one day, talking about how great it is that they don't have to pay for health insurance, as they enjoy a lump of government cheese. It will be interesting to see how the rest of the world fares when the economic engine known as the United States goes from neutral to a dead stop.

So how do you mandate the provision health care services regardless of pre-existing condition, limited co-pays and no limits on lifetime coverage and still protect the concept of individual freedom? How do you convince individuals to start and run companies that are required to sell dimes for 5 cents each? I have no idea. But, I'm listening.